Skip to main content

ENVISSION Toolkit

Evidence Navigation and Synthesis for Validating Interventions through Systematic, Scoping and Umbrella Reviews for ImplementatiON (ENVISSION Toolkit)

The Evidence Navigation and synthesis for Validating Interventions through Systematic and Scoping reviews for ImplementatiON (ENVISSION) Toolkit helps review teams make implementation evidence visible in systematic and scoping reviews. It provides five linked, editable instruments that carry an implementation lens from the review question to the final report, covering planning, searching, synthesis, appraisal, and reporting. The instruments are used alongside established standards such as PRISMA and GRADE, not in place of them. The toolkit was developed and tested by the Implementing Sustainable Evidence-based Interventions through Engagement (ISEE) Lab at the NYU School of Global Public Health across ten completed evidence syntheses between 2019 and 2026. All files are free to use and adapt under a CC BY 4.0 licence and come in editable and print-ready formats. New users should start with the ENVISSION Toolkit User Guide (S1).

 

Figure 1. The ENVISSION Toolkit at a glance

toolkit at a glance

Each of the five instruments is shown against the domains of evidence synthesis it serves (planning, searching, synthesis, appraisal, reporting) and labelled with its supplementary file number; the three appraisal instruments make judgements at the level of the individual study, the study design, and the body of evidence. Supporting resources are shown below in the Tables.

Start here: Which tool do I need?

Find your task in the left-hand column, then download the file listed. Each file number links to the file.

If your team needs to…UseFile
Understand how the toolkit fits togetherENVISSION Toolkit User GuideS1
Frame an implementation-focused question and build the searchENVISSION Planning Checklist and ENVISSION Search HedgesS2, S8
Judge risk of bias in each included studyENVISSION ASSESS 2.0*S7
Examine design-specific quality and transferability, or train reviewersENVISSION Critical Appraisal GuideS6
Grade certainty quickly for teaching or internal decisionsENVISSION Certainty Rating 1 and Evidence-Based PyramidS4, S9
Grade certainty for each outcome for publicationENVISSION Certainty Rating 2S5
Report the reviewENVISSION Reporting Checklist (with PRISMA 2020 or PRISMA-ScR)S3
Suggest an improvementENVISSION Toolkit Suggestions for Improvement FormS10

*please email the ISEE Lab at gph.isee@nyu.edu for access to the Google form

All toolkit files (version 1.0)

Each title links to the current file on the Open Science Framework. File numbers match the supplementary files of the published article.

FileTitleWhat it is for
S1 ENVISSION Toolkit User GuideHow the instruments fit together and which version of each to use
S2ENVISSION Planning ChecklistAn implementation-focused review question, extending PICO, that converts directly into a search structure
S3ENVISSION Reporting ChecklistImplementation-specific reporting items used alongside PRISMA 2020 or PRISMA-ScR
S4ENVISSION Certainty Rating 1A simplified certainty grade using the Evidence-
Based Pyramid, for teaching and internal decisions
S5ENVISSION Certainty Rating 2A full, domain-based certainty rating for each outcome, for publication
S6ENVISSION Critical Appraisal GuideDesign-specific questions on quality and transferability; also used to train reviewers
S7ENVISSION ASSESS 2.0* (template and online form)Design-routed risk-of-bias assessment for each included study
S8ENVISSION Search Hedges (S8a and S8b)Pre-built search terms for low- and lower-middle-income countries (S8a) and implementation research outcomes (S8b)
S9Evidence-Based PyramidLocates study designs by level of evidence; used Locates study designs by level of evidence; used
S10   ENVISSION Toolkit Suggestions for Improvement Form (online form)One place to send feedback on any instrument or resource
S11ENVISSION Toolkit Development Audit TrailHow each instrument was developed, cycle by cycle
 
Training videos: the ISEE Lab instructional videos on literature searching, research databases, screening and extraction in Covidence, PICO and other research frameworks, evaluating evidence, and EndNote can be used alongside the toolkit. Watch the instructional videos.

 

How to Cite

If you use the ENVISSION Toolkit, please cite the article and the toolkit files:

Peprah E, Vieira D, Pateña J, Gandhi K, Angelo L, Hameed T, et al. The ENVISSION Toolkit: iterative development and testing of an end-to-end toolkit for implementation-focused evidence synthesis. [Journal, year, DOI].

ENVISSION Toolkit, version 1.0. Open Science Framework. 10.17605/OSF.IO/7GE9Y

ENVISSION adapts and builds on established instruments, including PRISMA, GRADE, and CASP. Please also cite the original instruments you use.

 

Version note

These are the current files (version 1.0, released October 2026). Earlier development versions are kept in a clearly labeled archive on the Open Science Framework for transparency and should not be used for new reviews. When a file is updated, its version number and this page will change together.

 

Feedback

We welcome feedback from teams using the toolkit. To report a problem or suggest an improvement, use the ENVISSION Toolkit Suggestions for Improvement Form (S10). If you have completed a review using ENVISSION, email gph.isee@nyu.edu so we can add it to our public register of applications.